"Right now, oil prices are being driven up by speculation, not by sudden demand or lack of resources."
"You may recall that a few years ago, the average price of a gallon of regular gasoline climbed well over $4. That was down to oil speculation, pure and simple."
"What happened? Did we find a massive reserve of oil bubbling below the surface of an easily accessible stretch of land? Nope. It was speculation, too."
The writer goes on to suggest that President Obama could use speculation to reduce prices by making bold statements like: "putting billions of dollars into exploratory drilling", "opening up Anwar for oil extraction", and "demanding a minimum 60 mpg in vehicles by 2018". He even goes on to say that he "..also believe that some well-chosen words by our government, regardless of actual intention, could help avert that eventuality."
So I asked myself, "Is he really right that the price spike was solely a product of speculation and not driven by actual supply and demand?" While my understanding of "speculation" is that traders "guess" whether or not the supply will meet the demand and make financial bets accordingly. The writer seems to imply that speculation is independent of supply and demand, so that is the question I tackled. If I assumed wrong, disregard the first part of this post and read on anyway (still some interesting numbers!).
Did Supply and Demand Lead to the Price Spike?
First let us look at the production of oil over time from OPEC and non-OPEC countries.
As expected, OPEC related production is volatile and can increase or decrease based on demand, wars, or political reasons. However, looking at the non-OPEC producers paints a different picture. One thing to notice, non-OPEC producers are responsible for nearly 30% more of the oil production worldwide than the OPEC producers. Secondly, notice that the volatility in production rate is much lower for the non-OPEC producers and that production seemed to peak in the early 2000's and started declining right around when the prices started peaking. Going back to the OPEC graph, there was a sharp increase in production when the prices started going up, before a decline in production when the price of oil dropped.
Now lets look at the other side of the coin, the demand.
This figure shows the US consumption of oil per day over the past few years. While this is only the US, remember that the US consumes the most oil (3x as much as #2 China, 5x as much as #3 Japan, and 7x more than any European country). US consumption increased steadily from 1990 until prices started skyrocketing. The demand leveled off around 21 million barrels per day and quickly dropped to around 19 million barrels per day when the prices approached and topped $100/barrel. The prices quickly dropped back down, although still higher than pre-spike prices.
World oil demand dipped slightly at the same time the US demand dropped significantly. This last figure (from EIA.gov) also shows the same steady increase in demand from the start of the 1990's.
Ok now here is where I start inferring things, so take everything after this with a grain of salt and assume this is just one uniformed, non-expert opinion (obviously, this is a blog afterall, but I think it needs to be said). So lets recap, the demand has been steadily increasing over the past 15 to 20 years. Non-OPEC production increased with demand up until around 2000 when the production levels off, right around the time the oil prices started to increase. At the same time OPEC production had hit a recent low and started ramping up to meet the increasing demand that non-OPEC countries could no longer meet. As soon as the demand dropped off in 2008 in response to the $100+/barrel prices, the production took a quick cut.
So what does all of this mean? I think it means that non-OPEC producers hit a cap on the amount of oil they could economically produce. To meet the growing demand, the OPEC producers had to increase production. As basic economics suggest, the increased production from OPEC came from the most expensive sites they had, otherwise they would already be in operation. Prices started increasing until OPEC production peaked at 2006. They could no longer increase production without significant increases in the price of oil. The price spiked, and the production started increasing again. Finally, the market spoke and people finally started cutting back on oil consumption.
The reasons I don't think this was market manipulation by speculators, OPEC, or non-OPEC producers are as follows. 1) If OPEC could economically produce at the high levels of 2006-2009, they would have been doing so and pushing the non-OPEC production down. 2) Even when the price of oil passed $100/barrel, non-OPEC producers didn't increase production. If they can't increase production at $100+/barrel, they have reached their limit. 3) Once the demand in the US dropped, the price dropped.
I think that while speculation did drive up the cost of oil, I think it was from speculation about real supply and demand concerns, not just rampant speculation based on nothing but air. The data, to me, suggest that the world had hit a production limit at the low cost of oil. In order to produce the ever harder to access oil, the price had to increase to motivate companies to pay the millions (or billions) of dollars required to produce new wells. I think we should expect to see prices increase again (as they currently are) in response to the increasing demand. The market will speak, whether it says we don't value our current way of life at $5+/gallon of gas, or it will say we do.
Confidence in data (9). Confidence in analysis (6).




No comments:
Post a Comment