Monday, September 2, 2013

Update on Studying for Quals

I am a little over a month away from taking quals.  I am nervous, scared, anxious, and confident.  I have enough time to get a lot of practice quals in and really hammer home the stuff I'm still struggling with.  But, it is a grind like I didn't expect.  The biggest thing I have avoided so far is actually just sitting down and doing problems.  I need to do more of that.  I've taken good notes and had quite a few great conversations with my lab-mates about topics we all struggle with.  Having that support group has been invaluable, so I have to make sure to help out as much as possible when/if I am around when a new crop of kids comes through!

I've had 3 practice qualifying exams so far.  They all went relatively well, with Quantum being the most iffy, but also the most useful.  That exam is the one that I have the most uncertainty about, not knowing exactly how to prioritize the material/concepts/methods etc.  The practice qual I was given was very helpful and allowed me to flesh that out a little bit.  The other two went well, but definitely not perfect. 

I'm actually a little behind schedule, but I think that the remaining material will move faster than the first section.  There is a lot of overlap and as I do more practice quals, I can focus more and more on the things I am missing and be confident in the areas that I am consistently doing well.  I need to reorganize my schedule and be consistent with planning new quals with friends.  

A big wrinkle came up last week, Dani is going to Norway for 5 weeks!  She found out and left within 3 days, which was pretty crazy.  It has definitely been weird not having her around.  I am hoping this means I can actually study a little more than I normally would, since I am not as motivated to go home and hang out with her.  We'll see if that is true or not.  

Anyway, the purpose of quals is learning the material, not passing the exams, so I guess I better get back to studying!! 

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

"Are Electric Cars Really That Polluting?" - Forbes

I just read a well written article over at Forbes.com breaking down the costs and benefits of electric vehicles. I would have run the numbers a little differently, and the explanations in a few sections are lacking, but still pretty thorough. You don't see many mainstream news articles that don't butcher scientific terminology and understand, so this article pleased me. I think it is important for journalists to accurately deliver news to promote energy literacy.

Few things to note:


  • He included upstream carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from electricity generation (including extraction, construction, and transportation) while gasoline did not get the same treatment. He did seem to include this in the conclusion drawn from these comparisons though.
  • He mentioned the amount of mercury and other heavy earth metals released from burning coal is orders of magnitude higher than the mined amount of lithium and other heavy metals for batteries. However, battery production will likely increase by orders of magnitude if the 100 million electric car number is to be reached. What, then, is the comparison? And is it significant? What are the emissions from mining these things on a per kW capacity basis?
  • Increased demand from electric cars will allow higher overall penetration of renewables onto the grid, alleviating some of the intermittent issues that must be addressed by adding more gas-fired power plants.
Really interesting source from the article:
"Transitions to Alternative Vehicles and Fuels" - 2013, National Academy of Sciences



Friday, July 19, 2013

Summer of Quals

I thought it might be interesting to post a little bit every week or so about taking my qualifying exams.  I am doing this more because I think it will be interesting to go back when I am done and look at the change over the course of the next 11+ weeks.  Might be even more interesting to look back in 3 years when I graduate and laugh at these posts.  We will see.

Qualifying exams are a set of exams that must be passed in order for a student to become a Ph.D "candidate". In my case, there are three 30 minute verbal exams.  My three topic areas are thermodynamics, physical gas dynamics/combustion, and quantum mechanics.  Typically, you get two shots at passing them before you are kindly asked to take your Master's degree and go home.

This week was my first week of studying.  I'm mostly on schedule minus a few hours of working out problems.  It hasn't been terrible or great, simply feels like studying for finals.  But, this feeling concerns me because I typically get burnt out studying for finals after about a week.  Since I don't actually have an exam coming up in the next few days like typical finals, the stress level is definitely lower (or at least a different kind of stress) which made the process not as all consuming and frustrating.

Coming into studying, I had this weird bipolar view of what the experience might be like, assuming it would somehow be both.  On the one hand, I thought it would be the worst 2.5 months of my life, constantly with my head in a book, strung out on stress and lack of sleep, dreaming of equations and failing tests, and simply hating life.  On the other hand, I imagined a glorious academic endeavor filling me with warmth as I connected the dots between all of the subjects I so thoroughly enjoy.  I imagined sitting in a library in an old hardwood chair with the sun flowing in as I flipped through pages and pages of textbooks, all of them actually making sense.

Of course it is something in the middle.  It is like studying for finals that are months away, not necessarily enjoyable but less stressful because the hammer isn't in 48 hours.  It is a ton of material to cover in a short time but it is always faster the second (or third) time through.  It isn't ah-ha easy, yet it isn't as impossibly difficult as the first time you see it.  It is hard work and dedication, sitting in an office for hours and hours every day relearning something you think you already know.  It is practicing problems you've already solved on topics you thought you knew, realized you didn't, and then realized again that, 'Yea, I guess I did get it'.

It will be a journey I think, one that most of my friends look back on with some reverence and honest acknowledgement that the process sucked but that it was ultimately gratifying.  This is why I thought it would be fun to chronicle.  How many weeks will it take to become jaded and stressed out?  When will the quals horror dreams become nightly (I've already had 2 that I can remember)?  At what point will I snap and want to quit, think I know nothing, and feel like it is impossible to stay on track?  How many weeks after I finish (crossing my fingers I "finish" the first pass through) will I admit that it was all worth it?  How much coffee will I consume in the process (up to 5 cups in 5 days, not too shabby, par for the course)?  Will I succeed?

Let's do this.

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

Peace and Friendship



Raouf Mohseni/AP - Iranian revolutionary Guards personnel watch the launch of a Zelzal missile during military maneuvers outside the city of Qom on Tuesday.

I read this article today where Iranian state media said that a missile launching exercise and secret tours of secret hidden missile silos was a show of "peace and friendship" to neighboring countries. Maybe they are trying to keep peace by a show of force, keeping other countries from attacking them, but that definitely isn't a show of friendship. Either way, Iran seems to be flexing their muscles as the U.S. and NATO are in the midst of displaying their own power in the region. With the draw down of U.S. troops from Iraq and Afghanistan, Middle-East uprisings, NATO missions in Libya, and the Isreal-Gaza-floatilla mess, Iran seems to be getting a little antsy. I hope the chaos, unknown, and fear in the region passes without any more wars. I hope the people of the region can gain freedom and peace without the need for more wars and bloodshed. Unfortunately, the Iranian "war expo" didn't seem to have the intent.

Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Mis(Leading)Information

I have been trying to find an informative, reliable, and consistent source of energy related news. Luckily, I have a few friends from UT that have started their own energy related blogs, but they are updated relatively infrequently and each have their own niche they focus on. I am looking for a broader source that covers topics ranging from new technology developments, new trends in consumption and efficiency, energy policy, and foreign energy affairs. I still haven't found such a place.

My most recent attempt was Inhabitat.com. Inhabitat.com was started by a designer that wanted to highlight sustainable technologies, designs, and architecture. The website is a great source for finding new technologies and designs that are being talked about around the world but it is severely lacking in its accurate, educated portrayal of the technologies. Over and over the articles from Inhabitat.com leave out important details, answers to obvious questions and make technical mistake after technical mistake. Below I have listed just a few examples from an article that are either wrong or grossly misleading. Yes I am an engineer, so I am more skeptical and may notice mistakes that are not obvious to non-engineers. That does not mean it is OK for those errors to exist. Why not educate people on how these technologies work, what their pros and cons are, and how that compares to current designs and technologies?


"...each Oyster will be capable of producing 300-600 KW of electricity."
-This leads people to believe that the Oyster will produce between 300 and 600 kilowatts (kW not KW) at any given time. Actually, they are quoting a peak rating (or capacity) of the unit. It is entirely possible, and very likely, that the unit will produce no power at certain times of the day.

"Once completed, the farm will be able to provide enough energy for 3000 homes."
-The "provides enough energy for X homes" catchphrase is commonly used, and unfortunately commonly misunderstood, in mainstream media. First of all, the article leaves out the assumptions made about how much energy a home uses as well as how often the Oyster will operate at a specific power output. Second of all, this is wrong. I understand the need to explain things in terms that people can understand if they don't have any perspective on how much power their home uses, but this is misleading and does not educate the reader at all. This statement screams to me with a need to educate people on the difference between power and energy. Also, with the increased focus on renewable energy and the constant discussions of renewable energy technologies in the media, people should be educated, very simply, on the basics of how intermittent energy production and variable demand works.

Maybe the mistake I made was to assume I can find a single source that covers the energy industry thoroughly and completely while maintaining accuracy. And I understand that it is tough to toe the line between technical writing and mainstream media, but if we could get the facts straight, portray the information in an easy to understand way, and inject a tiny bit of new information for readers each time, we would make a ton of progress.

Or perhaps I just need to find 15 or so blogs like those my UT friends have started and get used to the mainstream media screwing it up.


Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Friday, May 13, 2011

One to Learn From

Phil Jackson is likely going to retire this year and never coach another basketball game again. Coached three of the greatest basketball players to ever live and won 11 NBA championships as a coach and 1 as a player. The Zen Master could be considered one of the best leaders of our time; harnessing desire, tempering egos, and building a team. Cheers to him for his success and being someone we can learn a lot from.

Great Article by Bill Simmons