Tuesday, June 21, 2011

Mis(Leading)Information

I have been trying to find an informative, reliable, and consistent source of energy related news. Luckily, I have a few friends from UT that have started their own energy related blogs, but they are updated relatively infrequently and each have their own niche they focus on. I am looking for a broader source that covers topics ranging from new technology developments, new trends in consumption and efficiency, energy policy, and foreign energy affairs. I still haven't found such a place.

My most recent attempt was Inhabitat.com. Inhabitat.com was started by a designer that wanted to highlight sustainable technologies, designs, and architecture. The website is a great source for finding new technologies and designs that are being talked about around the world but it is severely lacking in its accurate, educated portrayal of the technologies. Over and over the articles from Inhabitat.com leave out important details, answers to obvious questions and make technical mistake after technical mistake. Below I have listed just a few examples from an article that are either wrong or grossly misleading. Yes I am an engineer, so I am more skeptical and may notice mistakes that are not obvious to non-engineers. That does not mean it is OK for those errors to exist. Why not educate people on how these technologies work, what their pros and cons are, and how that compares to current designs and technologies?


"...each Oyster will be capable of producing 300-600 KW of electricity."
-This leads people to believe that the Oyster will produce between 300 and 600 kilowatts (kW not KW) at any given time. Actually, they are quoting a peak rating (or capacity) of the unit. It is entirely possible, and very likely, that the unit will produce no power at certain times of the day.

"Once completed, the farm will be able to provide enough energy for 3000 homes."
-The "provides enough energy for X homes" catchphrase is commonly used, and unfortunately commonly misunderstood, in mainstream media. First of all, the article leaves out the assumptions made about how much energy a home uses as well as how often the Oyster will operate at a specific power output. Second of all, this is wrong. I understand the need to explain things in terms that people can understand if they don't have any perspective on how much power their home uses, but this is misleading and does not educate the reader at all. This statement screams to me with a need to educate people on the difference between power and energy. Also, with the increased focus on renewable energy and the constant discussions of renewable energy technologies in the media, people should be educated, very simply, on the basics of how intermittent energy production and variable demand works.

Maybe the mistake I made was to assume I can find a single source that covers the energy industry thoroughly and completely while maintaining accuracy. And I understand that it is tough to toe the line between technical writing and mainstream media, but if we could get the facts straight, portray the information in an easy to understand way, and inject a tiny bit of new information for readers each time, we would make a ton of progress.

Or perhaps I just need to find 15 or so blogs like those my UT friends have started and get used to the mainstream media screwing it up.


No comments:

Post a Comment