Tuesday, July 23, 2013

"Are Electric Cars Really That Polluting?" - Forbes

I just read a well written article over at Forbes.com breaking down the costs and benefits of electric vehicles. I would have run the numbers a little differently, and the explanations in a few sections are lacking, but still pretty thorough. You don't see many mainstream news articles that don't butcher scientific terminology and understand, so this article pleased me. I think it is important for journalists to accurately deliver news to promote energy literacy.

Few things to note:


  • He included upstream carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from electricity generation (including extraction, construction, and transportation) while gasoline did not get the same treatment. He did seem to include this in the conclusion drawn from these comparisons though.
  • He mentioned the amount of mercury and other heavy earth metals released from burning coal is orders of magnitude higher than the mined amount of lithium and other heavy metals for batteries. However, battery production will likely increase by orders of magnitude if the 100 million electric car number is to be reached. What, then, is the comparison? And is it significant? What are the emissions from mining these things on a per kW capacity basis?
  • Increased demand from electric cars will allow higher overall penetration of renewables onto the grid, alleviating some of the intermittent issues that must be addressed by adding more gas-fired power plants.
Really interesting source from the article:
"Transitions to Alternative Vehicles and Fuels" - 2013, National Academy of Sciences



No comments:

Post a Comment